Winter Holiday Menu

select pick up date below for available treats

come in during open hours for additional available treats

We are now closed, you can still place a future order.

Pickup, ASAP (tomorrow)

December Sharing Boxes
December Ohio Pride Pies

December Sharing Boxes December Ohio Pride Pies

December Holiday Menu December Sharing Boxes December Ohio Pride Pies

December Holiday Menu

House made specialty treats, made with primarily organic ingredients, boxed up and ready to go for you this holiday season. Select the date of your desired pick up in the drop down menu above to see what items are available. Additional bakery goods are available for orders by the dozen by giving us a call at 614-784-2253, or stopping in during our open hours to grab some treats.

December Sharing Boxes

These holiday treats come by the dozen and can be ordered for your December gatherings.

Our classic festive cookie box contains 1 dozen cookies in a variety of: party sized sugar cutouts, gingerfolk, raspberry thumbprints, sprinkled spritz cookies, and snowballs.

$38.0038.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

Grab our gluten free festive cookie box filled with your favorite winter cookies! Our classic gf festive cookie box contains 1 dozen cookies in a variety of gluten free cookies: party sized sugar cutouts, raspberry thumbprints, and snowballs. Holiday cookie boxes come in a biodegradable plastic clamshell with a house designed holiday sticker.

$40.0040.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

Order a dozen of your favorite holiday cookies! You can choose from: 1 dozen full sized cut out cookies, a soft sugar cookie with vanilla icing in adorable winter shapes; 1 dozen raspberry thumbprints, a classic buttery cookie with organic raspberry preserves filling the center; 1 dozen gingerfolk, a crisp gingerbread cookie spiced just right, featuring fresh orange zest and cream cheese pipping; or 1 dozen snowballs, a round pecan shortbread cookie sprinkled with powdered sugar. Select your 1 dozen cookie variety below, along with the pick up date.

$36.0036.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

Order a dozen of your favorite gluten free holiday cookies! You can choose from: 1 dozen full sized cut out cookies, a soft sugar cookie with vanilla icing in adorable winter shapes; 1 dozen raspberry thumbprints, a classic buttery cookie with organic raspberry preserves filling the center; or 1 dozen snowballs, a round pecan shortbread cookie sprinkled with powdered sugar. Select your 1 dozen cookie variety below, along with the pick up date.

$36.0036.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

Grab our festive cookie box filled with 1 dozen party sized cut out cookies! Festive cookie boxes come in a biodegradable plastic clamshell with a house designed holiday sticker.

$35.0035.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

Grab our festive gluten free cookie box filled with 1 dozen party sized gf cut out cookies! Festive cookie boxes come in a biodegradable plastic clamshell with a house designed holiday sticker.

$37.0037.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

a kit with everything you need for stress-free cookie decorating for your gathering. each box includes: 12 winter themed party sized cut out cookies, covered with rich vanilla buttercream icing, 2 bags of buttercream icing, seasonal sprinkles, and instructions.

$38.0038.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

a kit with everything you need for stress-free cookie decorating for your gathering. each box includes: 12 winter themed party sized gluten free cut out cookies, covered with rich vanilla buttercream icing, 2 bags of buttercream icing, seasonal sprinkles, and instructions.

$40.0040.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

Our festive cupcake boxes contain one dozen party size cupcakes. You can choose from 1 dz gingerbread cupcakes with creamcheese whipped icing or 1 dz eggnog cupcakes with locally produced Watershed bourbon icing, topped with fresh ground nutmeg Please select the day and cupcake flavor you'd like in the drop down menu below. Gingerbread cupcakes $45/dozen Eggnog cupcakes $50/dozen

$45.0045.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

Our festive cupcake boxes contain one dozen party size cupcakes gf cupcakes. You can choose from 1 dz gf gingerbread cupcakes with creamcheese whipped icing or 1 dz gf eggnog cupcakes with locally produced Watershed bourbon icing, topped with fresh ground nutmeg Please select the day and cupcake flavor you'd like in the drop down menu below. Gingerbread cupcakes $55/dozen Eggnog cupcakes $60/dozen

$55.0055.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

a delightful way to have fresh baked sticky buns for the whole family. Each tray includes: 12 mini sticky buns, frozen in a compostable bakeable tray, icing, and instructions for proofing and baking. Please select from our vanilla sticky buns, a classic cinnamon roll with vanilla buttercream, or the bourbon pecan sticky buns, with pecans rolled into the center and a Watershed Distillery bourbon icing. Take and Bake sticky buns are frozen and need 6-8 hours to proof before baking. They come with proofing and baking instructions.

$28.0028.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

December Ohio Pride Pies

Made from scratch in small batches, using local primarily organic produce and house-made organic crusts. Pies are 10’’ and serve 8-10 people.

classic, lightly spiced pumpkin pie in an organic whole wheat crust, made with house roasted organic pumpkins from Three Creeks Produce.

$40.0040.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

classic, lightly spiced pumpkin pie in an organic gluten free crust, made with house roasted organic pumpkins from Three Creeks Produce.

$44.0044.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

rich, carmely pecan pie in an organic whole wheat crust, made with freshly toasted pecans and maple syrup from Shrock Farm

$40.0040.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

rich, carmely pecan pie in an organic gluten free crust, made with freshly toasted pecans and maple syrup from Shrock Farm

$44.0044.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

creamy, lightly spiced sweet potato pie with chunks of house roasted organic sweet potatoes from Weaver’s, baked into an organic whole wheat crust.

$40.0040.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

creamy, lightly spiced sweet potato pie with chunks of house roasted organic sweet potatoes from Weaver’s, baked into an organic gluten free crust.

$44.0044.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

perfectly sweetened dutch apple pie in an organic whole wheat crust and a house-made spiced crumble topping, made with Ohio apples from Ochs Fruit Farm

$44.0044.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

perfectly sweetened dutch apple pie in an organic gluten free crust and a house-made gluten free spiced crumble topping, made with Ohio apples from Ochs Fruit Farm

$48.0048.00 USD Unavailable

Unavailable

select date

Regular Hours
Monday - Tuesday: Closed

Wednesday- Friday: 9 am - 5:30 pm

Saturday and Sunday: 10 am - 4:00 pm

Special End of Year Hours
Closed Wednesday December 27- Sunday January 7
(reopening Wednesday January 10, 2024)

masks encouraged

3870 N. High St.
Columbus, OH 43214

for additional orders call:

614-784-2253

for general inquiries email: info@pattycakebakery.com